Sen. Kuderer is wrong that health care is a right

As an attorney, I was amazed to read that Democratic State Sen. Patty Kuderer from the 48th Legislative District (also an attorney) thinks health care is a right (, May 19). What has she been smoking? Does she know of a secret part of the Bill of Rights the rest of us don’t know about?

Health care is absolutely and obviously not a right under American law.

Health care is not mentioned in the U.S. Constitution, nor is a right to it mentioned anywhere in Washington’s Constitution. This is the very kind of elitist Democrat we don’t need in Olympia; we’ve already got a bunch of those down there from Seattle.

Her opponent, Michelle Darnell, is a much better choice for the Eastside who is not captured by the Seattle Left. She has not been sipping on the Kool Aid that causes progressives to create entitlements out of thin air.

Does Sen. Kuderer also naively believe that people have a right to a job? To a house? To recreation? To a vacation? These are Euro-socialist rights that have zero basis in American law. As a senator and attorney, Ms. Kuderer should know this.

Instead, she misleads Kirklanders with a bogus interpretation of the law to further her Seattle-style agenda.

As her opponent Libertarian Michelle Darnell says, it’s a great goal to have lots of health care that is accessible and affordable, it’s a great ideal; but not a right. Someone has to be the adult in the room.

Ms. Kuderer, please stop bastardizing the notion of real rights and propagating legal myths to get yourself elected. Please show some legal integrity, and realize Kirkland and the Eastside don’t want to be like Seattle and that health care is not a right.

Jeff Jared,


More in Letters to the Editor

Falcone is the smart choice | Letter

In the race for Kirkland City Council Pos. 6, Amy Falcone is… Continue reading

Falcone is the right choice | Letter

We are writing to recommend Amy Falcone for Kirkland City Council. As… Continue reading

Vote for Falcone | Letter

I am writing to support Amy Falcone for Kirkland City Council Pos.… Continue reading

Encouraging innovation | Letter

Earlier this year, I had a kidney transplant and it changed my… Continue reading

Give up now! | Letter

I believe that our forefathers didn’t pass the Second Amendment to our… Continue reading

Where have the ospreys gone? | Letter

For years I have watched a pair of ospreys raise chicks in… Continue reading

That entangled meme | Letter

Thanks to Sherman Peters (Reporter, Sept. 6) readers were fed glib history.… Continue reading

A nation of laws | Letter

In the United States, which has a population of about 330 million… Continue reading

Only the names have changed | Letter

Sept. 1 marked 80 years since Hitler invaded Poland and started World… Continue reading

Police shouldn’t become nannies | Letter

I am tired of police accountability; what about public accountability? Nowhere in… Continue reading

This week in letters: Kirkland Summerfest, right to bear arms

Thousands of asylum seekers from El Salvador, Guatemala, and Honduras — some… Continue reading

Integral to this country | Letter

On Aug. 2, Mr. Roger Clarke-Johnson’s letter (Bothell-Kenmore Reporter, Aug. 2) argued… Continue reading