Jury awards $4.25 million in Evergreen Hospital negligence case

A King County jury verdict awarded $4,248,200 today to the family of a Seattle area girl born with severe brain damage in 2003 after a traumatic delivery at Evergreen Hospital in Kirkland.

  • Monday, October 13, 2008 5:27pm
  • News
Evergreen Hospital Medical Center is Kirkland's largest employer

Evergreen Hospital Medical Center is Kirkland's largest employer

A King County jury verdict awarded $4,248,200 today to the family of a Seattle area girl born with severe brain damage in 2003 after a traumatic delivery at Evergreen Hospital in Kirkland.

After deliberating for over 3 days after the five week trial in Tavares vs. Evergreen Hospital, the jury found the hospital negligent based upon claims they ignored signs of severe fetal distress and failed to timely notify a doctor, which resulted in the infant’s asphyxiation for over 20 minutes prior to an emergency C-section being performed.

The five-year-old child from Maple Valley is now severely disabled, suffering from cerebral palsy and brain damage. As a result of oxygen deprivation, the full term child was born with retardation, severe disabilities, cerebral palsy, and a much shortened live expectancy.

“This tragedy was caused when attending nurses did not notify a doctor in time to do a crash C-section which could have prevented the injury,” said attorney John Budlong, who with attorney Ron Bemis, represented the family of the child.

The hospital denied any liability by its nurses and claimed the cause was pre-existing injury occurring days before entering the hospital.

The jury, however, sided with the plaintiffs who claimed that the delay in performing a C-section was a cause of the injuries to the infant.

“When there are signs of fetal distress, prompt intervention is required, and these patients did not receive that intervention in time to ensure the birth of a healthy child” Budlong said.

“By this verdict the jury has held the hospital answerable for not providing safe and timely care to its patients in the circumstances,” added Bemis.

The award includes future medical and home care expenses, lost future earnings capacity, and past medical expenses, past and future pain and suffering, and other general damages for the child.


In consideration of how we voice our opinions in the modern world, we’ve closed comments on our websites. We value the opinions of our readers and we encourage you to keep the conversation going.

Please feel free to share your story tips by emailing editor@kirklandreporter.com.

To share your opinion for publication, submit a letter through our website https://www.kirklandreporter.com/submit-letter/. Include your name, address and daytime phone number. (We’ll only publish your name and hometown.) We reserve the right to edit letters, but if you keep yours to 300 words or less, we won’t ask you to shorten it.

More in News

Co-owners Sarah Cassidy and Luke Woodward stand in front of The Grange (photo by Cameron Sheppard)
Co-owners Sarah Cassidy and Luke Woodward stand in front of The Grange (photo by Cameron Sheppard)
How a King County restaurant and farm work together to make a true farm-to-table experience

The Grange prepares sustainably produced meals pulled from the soil of the Snoqualmie Valley.

NW Carpenters Union members strike in front of downtown Bellevue construction site (photo by Cameron Sheppard)
Carpenters union strike interupts some prominent Eastside construction projects

Union representative says members are prepared to strike “as long as it takes.”

design rendering of ‘The Pine’ complex (courtesy of MainStreet Property Group)
‘The Pine’ 140-unit housing development breaks ground in Kirkland

The eco-friendly building design will aim to “embrace the natural environment”.

Map of proposed landfill expansion sites (screenshot from King County website)
Waste management expert knocks county’s plan to expand landfill

The waste management advocate said the decision to expand seems pre-determined despite assessment.

Participants in fundraiser previous event (courtesy of Alzheimer’s Association Washington State Chapter)
Walk To End Alzheimer’s returns to Eastside on Sept. 25

Alzheimer’s Association moves forward with plans for an in-person event.

file photo
State employees including first responders sue state over vaccine mandate

The lawsuit filed on behalf of more than 90 plaintiffs claims Inslee’s order is unconstitutional.

Pixabay photo
Union carpenters to go on strike, expected to impact Eastside Microsoft projects

Members authorized strike after rejecting AGC offer for the fourth time.

file photo
The state’s hospitals face “unprecedented collapse” amid COVID uptick warn healthcare unions

Union spokeperson says understaffing was a problem even before the pandemic.

Most Read