Judge Veronica Alicea-Galván’s courtroom just after hearing arguments on the I-27 lawsuit. From left to right: Mark Cooke, State Rep. Drew Stokesbary, Joshua Freed, Jeff Slayton. Courtesy of Casey Jaywork

Judge blocks I-27, saves supervised consumption sites

A ballot petition designed to obstruct King County’s public health response to the heroin crisis has been struck down by King County Superior Court Judge Veronica Alicea-Galván.

She ruled that I-27 is “invalid, null and void because it extends beyond the scope of the local initiative power” because it tried to override the authority of public health authorities and is thus unfit for the February 2018 ballot.

As previously reported, in September 2016 a public health task force recommended supervised drug consumption sites (called Community Health Engagement Locations, or CHELs) as part of a comprehensive response to the opioid/heroin overdose epidemic. Similar sites have operated for decades in other countries, without any known overdose deaths. A growing medical consensus recognizes supervised consumption sites as a healthier alternative to incarceration for drug crimes.

“Studies from other countries have shown that supervised injection facilities reduce the number of overdose deaths, reduce transmission rates of infectious disease, and increase the number of individuals initiating treatment for substance use disorders without increasing drug trafficking or crime in the areas where the facilities are located,” says the American Medical Association, which endorses such sites.

“Around 100 supervised consumption spaces currently operate in Australia, Canada, Switzerland, Norway, Germany and the Netherlands, and multiple studies show that these sites save lives and can help to connect people struggling with substance abuse to the services they need,” said Michael Ninburg, executive director of the Hepatitis Education Project and another member of Protect Public Health, according to a press release. “These programs are proven to reduce the risk of fatal overdose and prevent transmission of HIV and hepatitis C, as well as to reduce outdoor drug use in neighborhoods. Our current approach to the opioid crisis isn’t working. We need to do more, and (this) decision will allow us to do so.”

As previously reported, the argument made by attorney Knoll Lowney against I-27 went like this:

1. Local ballot initiatives can’t take away authority delegated to city officials by the state legislature. “An initiative is beyond the scope of the initiative power if the initiative involves powers granted by the legislature to the governing body of a city, rather than the city itself,” reads one quotation from the judgment in Mukilteo Citizens for Simple Gov’t v. City of Mukilteo. And another from City of Sequim v. Malkasian: “Stated another way, the people cannot deprive the city legislative authority of the power to do what the constitution and/or a state statute specifically permit it to do.”

2. State law delegates health decisions to local health officials—specifically, the Local Health Officer and the Board of Health.

3. Therefore, local ballot initiatives cannot override public health decisions made by local health authorities, including how to address the opioid crisis.

On Oct. 16, Alicea-Galván agreed, declaring I-27 “invalid, null and void,” and enjoining the King County Council and the director of King County Elections from putting it on the ballot.

You can read her entire ruling here.

“This is a major victory for public health, and will allow us to take the steps we need to implement an effective harm reduction approach to help those suffering from addiction to get the help that they need,” said Dr. Bob Wood, former director of the HIV/AIDS program at Public Health Seattle/King County, according to the release. “If I-27 was allowed to go to the ballot, other critically important and effective public health policies would also have been put at risk, including needle exchange programs, or even vaccination requirements.”

King County Council also voted on Oct. 16 to approve an alternative to I-27 that could have appeared alongside it on the February ballot. That alternative would have allowed voters to opt for two pilot CHEL sites (which would almost certainly be sited in willing host cities, though that was not explicit in the ordinance). Chair Joe McDermott and council members Jeanne Kohl-Welles, Rod Dembowski, Larry Gossett, and Claudia Balducci voted in favor of ordinance 2017-0420, while Reagan Dunn, Kathy Lambert, Pete von Reichbauer and Dave Upthegrove voted against. Assuming Alicea-Galván’s ruling stands, the alternative is now moot.

Explaining his vote via email afterward, Upthegrove said he’d wanted “to ensure the county doesn’t move forward on locating a facility within a city that has adopted a policy to not permit them in their city…My main argument today against the alternative was the absence of any such assurances.”

More in News

President’s emergency declaration sparks immediate legal backlash

Attorney General Bob Ferguson said his team will sue the White House if federal funds originally intended for Washington state are interrupted.

Bill targets sexual health curriculum in Washington schools

Senate Bill 5395 is co-sponsored by 17 Democratic representatives and introduced by Sen. Claire Wilson, D-Federal Way.

According to King County’s Mental Illness and Drug Dependency (MIDD) annual report, Seattle had the highest rate of people using services at 36 percent of the total, followed by 31 percent from South King County, 18 percent from the greater Eastside, and 7 percent from north county including Shoreline.
Study shows King County’s treatment funding is making progress

A document on the county’s .1 percent health sales tax was accepted Wednesday by the county council.

Children’s play area at Seadrunar. Photo by Lauren Davis via Facebook
Seedy side of Seadrunar: Drug rehab center accused of neglect, exploitation

Public records reveal that Seattle facility was accused of neglecting children and clients in its care.

Southbound traffic backs up as northbound drivers cruise on with ease on the Highway 99 viaduct on Tuesday, Jan. 8, 2019. (Andy Bronson / The Herald)
WSDOT hopes ‘Viadoom’ habits continue

The department credits commuters with adapting to the closure and mitigating impacts.

New Friends of Youth CEO, Paul Lwali, will replace Terry Pottmeyer. Courtesy photo.
Friends of Youth hires new CEO

Pottmeyer steps down; Lwali becomes new Friends of Youth CEO.

Russell Wilson and Ciara spoke Friday at the Tukwila Library to Foster students and other attendees as their Why Not You Foundation joined forces with the King County Library System and JPMorgan Chase to launch the DREAM BIG: Anything is Possible campaign. Photo by Kayse Angel
Russell Wilson and Ciara launch DREAM BIG campaign

Partnership with King County libraries dovetails with scholarship program for local students.

Somali community faces SeaTac displacement

Proposed redevelopment threatens the heart of the Somali business community.

One of the ‘snowiest’ months on record

Citizens fled to stores to stock up on needed supplies; City staff worked to keep roads clear.

Most Read