Why free market health care does not work

The arguments made by Jeff Jared in favor of free market health care should not go unanswered. Here are some reasons why the purely free market does not work for health care:

  • Like any private corporation, the priority of insurance companies is their own bottom line and a return to their shareholders. Your health is secondary.
  • The offering of “bare bones” insurance is a race to the bottom. It’s little better than an illusion.
  • The proliferation of private insurance companies and the accompanying maze of coverage details requires every doctor’s office to employ added staff. This, in turn, leads to higher costs.
  • The costs of running insurance companies is about 15 percent of the cash flow. For single payer systems, it is less than 5 percent.
  • Any insurance system relies on a sufficiently broad base to spread out costs. This is why the mandate in Obamacare is a critical part of limiting costs. You cannot let the young opt out just because they believe they will live forever.
  • Buying health care is not like buying a car. You do not shop around for the cheapest heart surgeon.
  • Over many decades, the American system of private insurance has been shown to cost twice as much and to lead to an inferior level of health.

David Malcolm,

Kirkland

More in Letters to the Editor

Are pesticides needed? | Letter

Ms. Mayor, We are residents of Holmes Point for several years now… Continue reading

Display of leadership | Letter

The Mueller Report is done. Get ready for fiery arguments on “criminality,”… Continue reading

Homelessness and the right to survive | Letter

Do homeless persons have a constitutional and civil right to occupy and… Continue reading

Affordable prescriptions needed | Letter

Americans pay the highest brand-name drug prices in the world. I ask… Continue reading

A short changed public | Letter

Representing Washington Physicians for Social Responsibility, I was one of dozens of… Continue reading

Earth Day 2019 | Letter

Much like making a New Year’s resolution, Earth Day is a perfect… Continue reading

A bit of relief | Letter

Working families, seniors, and the disabled deserve tax relief. By taxing less… Continue reading

Vote ‘yes’ to support public schools | Letter

Our children graduated in 2001, but we encourage our neighbors and community… Continue reading

Letters on EvergreenHealth measure | Letter

Vote yes on EverHealthy We’re writing to endorse EvergreenHealth’s proposed measure to… Continue reading

Most Read