Socialism won’t work for medical care

Mr. Scannell’s response, “Medicare-for-all makes sense,” (Kirkland reporter, Nov. 17) asserts that Mr. Jared’s letter was “lots of heat and no light” and “convulsive and childish.” But citing Scandinavia and Canada, with socialized medical systems, as good examples for us to follow, is misinformed.

First, such countries have small populations. Canada has 35 million (smaller than California’s 39 million), Finland & Norway are about 5 million each (smaller than Washington’s 7 million), and Sweden has 10 million. Compare this with the United States, with a population of 320 million.

Doing it for a small nation is much different than doing it in a mammoth one. How will it scale?

Second, the United States subsidizes the military defense of these countries, freeing up money to subsidize their socialism. (I agree we should not be spending so much on an offensive military, but that is for another conversation). If it were not for the U.S. subsidizing these countries’ national defense, their socialism might not appear so rosy.

Third, American and U.S. based companies and universities research, invent and discover most of the medical innovations that these countries after the fact enjoy. And it’s our (relatively) free-market health care system that attracts the best and the brightest from around the world. The super skilled and ambitious tend not to go into socialist fields. If we socialize our health system, we’ll see a medical brain drain.

We DO need to break up the medical industrial complex and medical professional guild system and reform medical licensing. The current system is monopolist with little accountability.

Socializing a system that that has not effectively addressed costs, is a failing proposition and unsustainable. A free market approach will allow economic forces to drive down costs and increase choice and quality of care. Government is the problem here not the solution.

Would we want our food, housing and clothing socialized too? A single payer system for computers, cell phones and cars? I think not. If socialism won’t work for these things, it won’t work for medical care.

Michelle Darnell,


More in Letters to the Editor

A modest debate about transparency | Letter to the editor

A Kirkland resident probes Rep. Springer’s support of SB 6617.

Who speaks for me? | Letter to the editor

The Kirkland resident recently attended a town hall meeting.

It’s time to demonstrate that progress is possible | Letter to the editor

A Kirkland resident is concerned about the use of a recent image in an editorial page cartoon.

Most recipients of public eduction don’t become killers | Letter to the editor

A North Bend resident responds to “Don’t ban guns, ban goverment schools.”

Ask Sen. Cantwell to cosponsor legislation to remove financial cancer screening barrier | Letter to the editor

A letter asking Sen. Maria Cantwell to cosponsor the Removing Barriers to Colorectal Cancer Screening Act this year.

You can’t have a shooting without first having a gun | Letter to the editor

A letter in response to a letter about banning public schools to prevent school shootings.

Vote ‘No’ on LWSD measures | Letter to the editor

It is difficult to keep up with the rising cost of living on the Eastside and tax increases won’t help.

Please support the futures of Lake Washington School District students

As a former Lake Washington School District student, I am proud of… Continue reading

Vote ‘yes’ Feb. 13 | Letter to the editor

As a current Washington State Legislator and former Kirkland mayor, I’ve seen… Continue reading