Atheism argument missed the point

Jared (“In support of atheism” letter in July 30 Kirkland Reporter) has more in common with theists than he realizes. Jared demonstrates admirably that even some atheists have limited powers of reasoning.

Dear Editor,

Jared (“In support of atheism” letter in July 30 Kirkland Reporter) has more in common with theists than he realizes. Jared demonstrates admirably that even some atheists have limited powers of reasoning.

He posits that theists and atheists are 99 percent alike because atheists believe in one less god than (mono)theists. This argument is loosely based on an argument that Dawkins uses in his wonderful book, The God Delusion.

The problem with his reasoning, though, is that he assumes there are 100 gods that we could possibly believe in. In fact there are an infinite number of gods one could choose to believe in (I’m sure you could make up a new one right now if you chose.).

Atheists believe in none of them while (mono)theists believe in one. The difference between one divided by infinity and zero divided by infinity are both zero, so they’re identical, right?

Actually I’d argue there’s a huge difference in the thought processes of someone who believes in a god or some other imaginary friend and someone who doesn’t. I look forward to the day when a presidential candidate who doesn’t have an imaginary friend can be elected to lead this country.

~Craig Fisher, Kirkland

More in Letters to the Editor

Raves for U.S. Postal Service | Letter

Thanks for the passionate service you and your crew delivered last week.… Continue reading

Funding solution | Letter

Easy way to get rid of King County funding struggles: get rid… Continue reading

Wrong and scary | Letter

I thought that we were living in a civilized society? Where all… Continue reading

Inslee and climate change | Letter

Gov. Jay Inslee appears ready to announce his 2020 presidential run. Considering… Continue reading

Neighborhood parking | Letter

We are all in favor of developing Kirkland for the better. However,… Continue reading

Kiwanis tree lot a huge success | Letter

The Kirkland community and surrounding neighborhoods came through once again this year… Continue reading

Thank you Rep. DelBene | Letter

The Building Our Largest Dementia (BOLD) Infrastructure for Alzheimer’s Act has just… Continue reading

A challenge to readers | Letter

[To Samantha Pak] I enjoyed your Windows and Mirrors story in the… Continue reading

Fraudster-in-Chief | Letter

In October 2016, a neighbor explained to me he was supporting then-presidential-candidate… Continue reading

A missed opportunity | Letter

Your article (“Let’s talk about race,” Bothell-Kenmore Reporter, Dec. 14) missed an… Continue reading

United we stand — divided we fall | Letter

I can’t really believe that there are people that believe if you… Continue reading

One way to address homelessness | Letter

Why is Seattle’s homelessness problem getting worse not better? Some people are… Continue reading